Those were my exact thoughts when I read this weeks recipe choice by Judy of Judy’s Gross Eats.

I had made marshmallows twice before, failing miserably both times. It was a recipe without eggs, and the gelatin fell to the bottom of the pan. So here I am again, nervous and anxious waiting for the results.

Three hours later…

They’re perfect! Fluffy, soft, and tasty. This gives me the confidence and encouragement to try raspberry marshmallows. Although, I think I’ll double the recipe next time. It wasn’t nearly as much to fill a half sheet pan. I don’t understand why Dorie chose the pan she did and not a 8×8 or 9×9? Well, I have to thank Judy for picking this recipe…for I’ve been thinking ‘I have to make a good marshmallow’ for months.

This entry was posted on Tuesday, April 15th, 2008 at 12:04 pm and is filed under Baking, Tuesdays With Dorie. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

23 Responses to “Attack of the marshmallow man!”

Nick Says:

Wow! They look fantastic! So fluffy and white. Where’s the hot chocolate to go with them? ;-)

Marie Says:

I think your marshmallows look scrummy!! Well done! Nice and fluffy! I opted to make some peanut butter cookie smores with mine!

Rebecca Says:

Ah, victory! I love the pic of the marshmallows in your hands. Fluffy and gorgeous. Way to go!

Jen Says:

Those look like little fluffy clouds! Nice job

Amanda Says:

Beautiful! I love the dish you used. So cute!

April Says:

ohhh, they look so good!

Judy (Judy's Gross Eats) Says:

Glad you tried again. They turned out so large and fluffy. Since no pan size was given in the recipe, I used an 11×7 and it worked perfectly.

mari Says:

Your marshmallows look fantastic! Welcome aboard, btw!

Dianne Says:

They look great! Glad they turned out well this go round.

Annemarie Says:

I’m so glad it worked out for you! And I totally agree on the pan size…doesn’t make sense.

Nikki Says:

How funny is that, I always use a recipe with no eggs and never have problems and I think I screwed this recipe up every way possible

eric Says:

i want to eat them right now.

Heather Says:

Great job! They look so yummy!

Beth G Says:

Beautiful!! They look so fluffy and delicious- you did a great job :O)

Holly Says:

They look wonderful! Nice work!

Natalie Says:

Wow, those are so huge and fluffy! Fantastic job, and I love the pictures!

Donna Says:

Your marshmallows are so perfectly white and BIG and square and fluffy! I love the hand in the bowl shot! Perfect Job!

Shari Says:

Your marshmallows look soft, fluffy, and delicious! Great job!

LyB Says:

So glad they turned out well for you, they look delicious! I prefer egg-less recipes though, less complicated! :)

zakia Says:

wow.. your marshmallows are so fluffy! great pics.

steph Says:

no failures this time! they look great!

Bre Says:

Hey, just posted about this on http://nycresistor.com

rebekka Says:

Those ARE perfect! I sure wish I had a dish like that to make my marshmallows in.

Leave a Reply

XHTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>